What to Order at Taylor Sam’s: A Guide for First-Time Guests

Walking into Taylor Sam’s for the first time comes with one small challenge: deciding what to order.

Breakfast classics share the menu with creative brunch dishes, sandwiches, burgers, bowls, and specialty coffee. Whether you already know what you’re craving or need a little direction, there are plenty of ways to get acquainted with the menu.

So, where should a first-timer begin?

Here are a few Taylor Sam’s favorites worth knowing about.

Start with a Classic: Taylor’s Benedict

For a first visit, Taylor’s Benedict is a natural place to start.

Taylor Ham gives the traditional Benedict a distinctly Jersey spin, paired with poached eggs and creamy hollandaise on an English muffin, with home fried potatoes on the side.

It’s familiar enough for anyone who loves a classic Benedict while still giving you a taste of Taylor Sam’s personality.

Try Something Different: Paco’s Breakfast

If your usual breakfast order feels a little too predictable, Paco’s Breakfast takes things in another direction.

Homemade crispy empanadas filled with seasoned ground beef are served with farm-fresh eggs, queso fresco, corn and black bean salsa, homefries, and fresh salsa.

It’s hearty, colorful, and a good introduction to the more playful side of the Taylor Sam’s menu.

Go Sweet, Savory & Spicy: Vicious Biscuit

The Vicious Biscuit is for anyone who wants a little bit of everything in one order.

A homemade cheddar-jalapeño biscuit is layered with creamy pimiento cheese and crispy buttermilk-fried cauliflower finished with hot honey glaze, plus your choice of egg and home fried potatoes.

Crunch, creaminess, sweetness, and heat all come together in a breakfast that’s anything but ordinary.

Keep It Fresh: Bravacado

Looking for something on the fresher side? Bravacado brings Taylor Sam’s take to avocado toast.

Artisan wheat toast is topped with creamy avocado, crispy bacon, ripe tomato, baby arugula, and two eggs prepared your way, with homefries alongside.

It’s a solid choice when you want something fresh without giving up the satisfying parts of breakfast.

Staying for Lunch? You Have Options

Breakfast may get a lot of attention, but Taylor Sam’s gives first-time guests plenty to explore beyond the morning favorites.

Honey B. Chicken combines grilled chicken, Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, and honey mustard on toasted brioche. If you’re craving a burger, the Monster Sam brings breakfast and lunch together with an Angus burger topped with Taylor ham, a fried egg, and American cheese.

Both come with hand-cut fries, making either an easy choice when eggs and pancakes aren’t what brought you in.

Pair It with Something from the Coffee Bar

A first Taylor Sam’s order doesn’t have to stop at the plate.

The NJ Transit combines hot chocolate, espresso, and frothed milk with cinnamon and chocolate drizzle, while the L.A. Metro brings together white chocolate, steamed milk, and espresso finished with whipped cream and white chocolate.

If you think these sound good, just wait until you hear about the drink specials that rotate monthly on the menu.

Prefer to keep things simple? Lattes, cappuccinos, macchiatos, Americanos, mochas, and other coffee-bar staples are available too.

Your First Order Probably Won’t Be Your Last

There isn’t one right way to order at Taylor Sam’s.

Start Jersey-style with Taylor’s Benedict. Go in a completely different direction with Paco’s Breakfast or the Vicious Biscuit. Choose Bravacado when something light and fresh sounds better, or make it lunch with Honey B. Chicken or the Monster Sam.

With locations in Brick and Bay Head, New Jersey, and St. Petersburg, Florida, Taylor Sam’s gives first-time guests plenty to discover beyond a single signature dish.

The harder decision might be what you’re ordering on visit number two.

Plan Your First Visit

Ready to find your Taylor Sam’s favorite? Visit Taylor Sam’s in Brick, NJ; Bay Head, NJ; or St. Petersburg, FL, explore the menu, and start with whatever catches your eye.

View the Taylor Sam’s menu or order online to start planning your first visit.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I order at Taylor Sam’s for my first visit?

Taylor’s Benedict is a great place to start if you want a signature breakfast with a New Jersey influence. Paco’s Breakfast and the Vicious Biscuit are good choices for something less traditional, while Bravacado offers a fresher option.

Does Taylor Sam’s serve more than breakfast?

Yes. In addition to breakfast and brunch favorites, Taylor Sam’s offers salads, bowls, sandwiches, burgers, tacos, pastries, and specialty coffee.

Does Taylor Sam’s have vegetarian options?

Yes. Taylor Sam’s has vegetarian-friendly choices, including dishes such as the Vicious Biscuit and other meat-free selections. Guests with specific dietary requirements should confirm ingredients and preparation with the restaurant.

Does Taylor Sam’s serve specialty coffee?

Yes. Taylor Sam’s offers specialty drinks such as the NJ Transit and L.A. Metro, along with monthly specials, and traditional espresso-bar favorites including lattes, cappuccinos, macchiatos, Americanos, and mochas.

Where are Taylor Sam’s locations?

Taylor Sam’s has locations in Brick, New Jersey; Bay Head, New Jersey; and St. Petersburg, Florida.